Jared Gilman

Ben

Rinzin Thonden

Elijah

Tennessee Luke

Desmond

Victoria Pommalath

Bailey

Kim Hernandez

Vanessa

Liora Kats

Candy / Anastasia (voice)

Sage Kirwan

Anastasia/Jen (voice)/Vanessa (voice)/Elijah's Hookup (voice)

Alexis Dixon

Jen

Danae Balladares

Abigail

Daniel Green

Father McNally

David J. Green

Father McNally (voice)

Nicole Borbone

Lola